Years of research and no answers: the mystery of Satoshi Nakamoto remains

Satoshi Nakamoto comes to life in Lugano with a statue that symbolizes the Bitcoin revolution

It's been more than 15 years since Bitcoin burst onto the scene with the publication of its whitepaper in October 2008, signed by an enigmatic figure: Satoshi Nakamoto. This pseudonym, which gave life to the first decentralized cryptocurrency, has unleashed one of the greatest mysteries of the digital age. Despite countless investigations, theories and speculations, Nakamoto's true identity remains an unsolved mystery. In this article, we explore why this enigma endures and what it tells us about Bitcoin's legacy.

The birth of a myth

On October 31, 2008, a document entitled Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System was posted on a cryptography mailing list. Signed by Satoshi Nakamoto, the text described a revolutionary system that eliminated the need for intermediaries in financial transactions. Just three months later, on January 3, 2009, Nakamoto mined the first Bitcoin block, known as the “genesis block,” embedding in it a symbolic message: “The Times 03/Jan/2009 Chancellor on brink of second bailout for banks.” This nod to the global financial crisis underlined Bitcoin’s mission: to offer an alternative to the traditional banking system.

In the early years, Nakamoto was active on forums and in emails, collaborating with developers such as Hal Finney and Gavin Andresen. However, in April 2011, after announcing that he was retiring to “work on other things,” he disappeared without a trace. Since then, Satoshi’s silence has fueled a mystery that neither researchers, journalists nor enthusiasts have been able to solve.

Theories and candidates

The lack of concrete information about Nakamoto has given rise to a cascade of theories. Some believe he is a brilliant individual, while others argue that he could be a collective. Among the most frequently mentioned suspects are:

  • Nick Szabo: A cryptographer known for his work on “Bit Gold,” a conceptual precursor to Bitcoin. Although Szabo denies being Nakamoto, his writing style and ideas have been compared to the whitepaper.
  • Dorian Nakamoto: A Japanese-American engineer whose real name (Satoshi Nakamoto) made him the target of a Newsweek investigation in 2014. Dorian, however, denied any links.
  • Craig Wright: An Australian computer scientist who claimed to be Nakamoto in 2016, but his evidence was widely discredited by the crypto community.
  • Hal Finney: One of the earliest Bitcoin adopters and recipient of the cryptocurrency's first transaction. His proximity to the beginnings of Bitcoin made him a logical candidate, although he passed away in 2014 without confirming anything.

Despite these names, no definitive evidence has emerged. Linguistic analyses, Bitcoin address tracing and journalistic investigations have always hit the same wall: Nakamoto's genius for remaining anonymous.

Why does it remain a mystery?

Satoshi’s anonymity seems no coincidence, but rather a deliberate decision. Nakamoto took meticulous measures to conceal his identity, such as using anonymous networks (such as TOR) and avoiding any personal data in his communications. This suggests that the creator of Bitcoin prioritized decentralization not only in its technology, but also in its very existence. By disappearing, he ensured that Bitcoin did not rely on a central figure, reinforcing its libertarian ethos.

Moreover, the passage of time has complicated matters. Wallets associated with Nakamoto, which contain approximately one million bitcoins (valued at tens of billions of dollars today), have remained untouched since 2011. This financial silence adds further intrigue: is Nakamoto alive, dead, or just watching from the shadows?

A legacy beyond identity

While the question “who is Satoshi Nakamoto?” remains unanswered, his impact is undeniable. Bitcoin has inspired an ecosystem of thousands of cryptocurrencies, challenged the dominance of central banks, and given a voice to those seeking financial autonomy. Some argue that knowing his identity might be irrelevant, as the real revolution lies in the technology he left behind.

However, the mystery also has a practical side. If Nakamoto were to reappear or be identified, it could influence the cryptocurrency market dramatically. A single movement of those dormant bitcoins could trigger a wave of speculation. For now, the crypto community lives with uncertainty, debating whether Satoshi’s anonymity is a blessing or a mystery that should one day be solved.